Person
Pius XII
Pontiff; Grusch attributes to him an information channel to the United States
1944–1945 · Historical figures (1933–2007) · Historical figure
In June 2023 David Grusch claimed that Pius XII passed to the Americans the information about the craft recovered in Italy and, in an interview in November 2023, that a message from him reached President Roosevelt through the OSS. The Vatican element does not appear in Pinotti's account of the RS/33 documents and, according to Metabunk, was added to the story by William Brophy Jr. after 2004. In June 2024 the Vatican Apostolic Archive rejected the claim: Marco Grilli, secretary to the prefect, said he did not know where Grusch got the information.
- Controversies
- Denial by the Vatican Apostolic Archive (June 2024), reported by it.wikipedia, which cites Catholic News Service and a video report by Virgilio.
- In June 2026 an anonymous Vatican source with access to the archives told NewsNation that he or she had found no references to the Magenta case nor any communications regarding a pope; NewsNation notes that this does not conclusively disprove the claim.
- Today
- Cited by Grusch in 2023. After the denial by the Vatican Apostolic Archive (June 2024), in June 2026 NewsNation reported that a search of the Vatican archives found no references to the case.
Documented authority
It measures how documented and verifiable what the person claims is, not their honesty. Each criterion is scored from 0 to 2.
- Credentials 2/2
- Pontiff: historical role certain; no known document attests to the alleged channel with the OSS.
- Direct access not applicable
- Not applicable: the role is attributed to him by third parties (Grusch, 2023).
- Evidence provided not applicable
- Not applicable: no claims of his own on the subject.
- Claims track record not applicable
- Not applicable: no claims of his own on the subject.
- Conflicts of interest not applicable
- Not applicable: no claims of his own on the subject.
Sources
- Very Exciting Time, episode 42: Magenta UFO (2024), with Grusch's 2023 claims (analysis, pro-disclosure)
- Incidente di Magenta, Italian Wikipedia (2024 Vatican denial) (other)
- CNS/USCCB: Vatican archives and alleged UFO secrets (2024) (press)
- NewsNation: search of the Vatican archives on the Magenta case (June 15, 2026) (press)
- Metabunk: discussion of the alleged 1933 UFO crash in Italy (analysis, skeptical)
On this site
Cases 1
- Magenta 1933: the alleged retrieval of a disc, known only from anonymous papers Disputed explanation
Timeline 3
- Apr 1945: Unverified account: U.S. troops allegedly took the Magenta craft at Vergiate
- Jun 2023: Grusch's first television interview, with Ross Coulthart on NewsNation
- Jun 2024: The Vatican Apostolic Archive: no known source for Grusch's claim about Pius XII
Open in the interactive archive The whole section: Directory of people
UAPgrade's entries are compiled with artificial intelligence (three verifiers with opposing roles) and checked against the sources listed above: how we work. Have a document that changes this entry? Bring it to the Investigations Unit.